CLT challenges SAT and ACT

In the belief that the SAT and ACT measure the wrong kind of learning, the CLT (Classic Learning Test) is intended to guide education back to what it considers real wisdom in the form of the classics (“The SAT and ACT Have a Classical Competitor,” The Wall Street Journal, Apr. 24). More than 150 colleges in the U.S., Canada, and Spain now offer students the option of submitting CLT scores for admission.

Yet from a pedagogical point of view, the use of the CLT is indefensible.  Unless a test is carefully aligned with the curriculum, it is not assessing what students have learned in class but instead what they bring to class in the form of their socioeconomic backgrounds.  Since schools today are under enormous pressure to prepare students for college or career, the overwhelming majority are going to emphasize knowledge and skills that are most in demand.

The classics no longer appeal to most students since they see little, if any, relevance to their lives.  That doesn’t mean the classics shouldn’t be taught, but it’s unlikely they will find many students interested.  The humanities are already losing students, and with the decline some colleges are closing such departments.  I expect the trend to accelerate as the cost of a college degree continues to rise.

(To post a comment, click on the title of this blog.)

2 Replies to “CLT challenges SAT and ACT”

  1. Humans need many things to live in what we hope will be a civilized society and whether or not the Classics will help anybody get a job, and who can say what kind of job it will be, I do not think universities doing away with their Classics Departments is a good idea. What separates we two-legged beasts from other beasts is just such things as being aware of past civilizations and the artefacts and literature they produced. Great literature helps us know that we are not unique nor are we special. We are just the latest iteration of humans. If that is a luxury, I still think it is a necessary one.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: